@NoahHaber @CAMARADES_ group (@DrKaitlynHair @profEmilySena @Maclomaclee and collaborators) did a crowdsourced review of publications with randomisation to @PLOSONE -requested completion of an ARRIVE checklist and the effect on adherence to reporting guide
@NoahHaber @EggletonKim I think this is the first one I mentioned: https://t.co/4mV5YQA5Ac
RT @FJRamage: @DuddaLeonie @openscience @ReproducibiliT Hair, K., Macleod, M.R., Sena, E. et al. A randomised controlled trial of an Interv…
@DuddaLeonie @openscience @ReproducibiliT Hair, K., Macleod, M.R., Sena, E. et al. A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus). Res Integr Peer Rev 4, 12 (2019). https://t.co/PHaMpb0grU Migh
RT @mattjhodgkinson: Randomised trial of ARRIVE reporting guidelines for animal research was done at @PLOSONE [I was an editor there at the…
RT @mattjhodgkinson: Randomised trial of ARRIVE reporting guidelines for animal research was done at @PLOSONE [I was an editor there at the…
RT @mattjhodgkinson: Randomised trial of ARRIVE reporting guidelines for animal research was done at @PLOSONE [I was an editor there at the…
Randomised trial of ARRIVE reporting guidelines for animal research was done at @PLOSONE [I was an editor there at the time, but not involved in the RCT]. Gillian Currie notes mandating use of ARRIVE by authors didn't improve reporting 😢 https://t.co/Gshbc
@JFronczekMD @GSCollins @PWGTennant @hildabast @sharpmelk In this context, we all know guidelines work, right? Except, they don’t always …https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN
@GilbreathDustin Great paper illustrating how you can adjust / drop parts of your planned protocol and describe why and how in detail https://t.co/Us0SLDQYMO
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus) published as: https://t.co/djHJr5vVeT #Research_Integrity_and_Peer_Review #biorxiv
@Edit0r_At_Large @chrisdc77 @BrianNosek Badges: https://t.co/ZSJ6TtnRMi Open peer-review: https://t.co/05BEFUM0VW Blinding: https://t.co/5qouTAO5tW Reporting guidelines: https://t.co/6TIMlKc1Bk Selective reporting (protocol): https://t.co/7QYUVDjWkr Peer-r
@edisgroup @wellcometrust @B_I_Tweets eg our RCT of compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN , with @KaitlynHair_ and @drEmilySena, showed that it didn't make any difference when journals demanded checklist completion - one of the driv
@PJirkof @VVoikar Making something “mandatory’ doesn’t make it happen - https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN - so we should see this as journals being on an improvement trajectory, rather than a binary compliant/non compliant. I think the ARRIVE2 framing helps prioriti
@nicolacullum @MaartenvSmeden I'm afraid making it mandatory doesn't help ...https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN
RT @Maclomaclee: @TraceyJWoodruff @CAMARADES_ @drEmilySena Thanks Tracey - Our reviewers are fabulous! Many of the same people contributed…
RT @Maclomaclee: @TraceyJWoodruff @CAMARADES_ @drEmilySena Thanks Tracey - Our reviewers are fabulous! Many of the same people contributed…
@TraceyJWoodruff @CAMARADES_ @drEmilySena Thanks Tracey - Our reviewers are fabulous! Many of the same people contributed to https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN and https://t.co/DugYP7U8Bc, and we are extremely grateful
RT @CarolynShore: A RCT of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus) - a checklist on its own is not enough h…
RT @Maclomaclee: @KDNyhan this afternoon, you'll hear if a "requirement" moved the needle at a journal - https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN - featurin…
@KDNyhan this afternoon, you'll hear if a "requirement" moved the needle at a journal - https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN - featuring @KaitlynHair_ and @drEmilySena #ReproducibilityInScience
Alas... "These results suggest that altering the editorial process to include requests for a completed #ARRIVE [Animal Research: Reporting of In Vivo Experiments] checklist is not enough to improve compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines." #ResearchIntegrity
@GrimshawJeremy Many parallels here with improving research ... just because something looks like it should work, doesn’t mean it will. https://t.co/6nPZ1zLaXN
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
Important study, showing it's important to test our interventions (like checklists, guidelines, etc.) designed to improve the fidelity of research reporting. My sense is that we're not going to get a lot of change with small interventions like these.
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
RT @EvanMayoWilson: A randomized trial finds that requiring a checklist does not, by itself, improve journal article reporting: https://t.c…
@jpleach246 Point being that just because something looks like it should work doesn’t mean it will - eg see our RCT of implementing a reporting guideline https://t.co/IxpuyG30iG - achieved nothing.
RT @ShonaHLang: Journals who request that their authors adhere to reporting guidelines (ARRIVE checklist) does not improve compliance. #rep…
Journals who request that their authors adhere to reporting guidelines (ARRIVE checklist) does not improve compliance. #reporting #compliance #reproducibility (IICARus)https://t.co/FkxJ2zHZkq #riprjournal
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus). by Hair K, Macleod MR, Sena ES, IICARus Collaboration https://t.co/ZMs9IYD7GJ
If you review papers, you should request this in your review.
A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus) https://t.co/AwwNF53QOF #riprjournal
RT @nutsci: RCT: requesting that authors complete the ARRIVE (animal research reporting) guidelines checklist at submission doesn't improve…
RT @nutsci: RCT: requesting that authors complete the ARRIVE (animal research reporting) guidelines checklist at submission doesn't improve…
RT @nutsci: RCT: requesting that authors complete the ARRIVE (animal research reporting) guidelines checklist at submission doesn't improve…
Sigh. My experience is similar with other reporting checklists.
RT @nutsci: RCT: requesting that authors complete the ARRIVE (animal research reporting) guidelines checklist at submission doesn't improve…
RT @nutsci: RCT: requesting that authors complete the ARRIVE (animal research reporting) guidelines checklist at submission doesn't improve…
@mwlangendam @ManojLalu
RCT: requesting that authors complete the ARRIVE (animal research reporting) guidelines checklist at submission doesn't improve reporting compliance https://t.co/W0z30gThTf (intervention was performed in 2015) "the median compliance was less than 40%"
Here is the link to the paper: https://t.co/CyS6HklEX9
While working as a #PLOSONE editor, I and a few colleagues collaborated with the amazing @KaitlynHair_ @drEmilySena and @Maclomaclee et al. to help design and carry out the data collection portion of this study. Thrilled it is now published!! Kudos to CAMA
Checklists can be a useful, as an aide memoir &/or conversation starter as part of a series of measures to improve #researchreporting but they alone are not a miracle cure....
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
RT @Maria_Kowalczuk: It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1…
It's not enough to ask for a checklist - no manuscript achieved full compliance with #ARRIVEguidelines in a study of 1689 papers submitted to PLOS ONE by @KaitlynHair_ @Maclomaclee and @drEmilySena in #riprjournal https://t.co/xndVto6XXp